California bill to ban mass balance vetoed by governor Newsom

A California bill aimed at clamping down on a recycled-content measurement methodology labelled an accounting trick ‘to mislead consumers’ has been vetoed by the governor of the US state.

In a letter to members of the California State Assembly, governor Gavin Newsom said he was concerned that proposals in Assembly Bill 2253 to expand documentation requirements would “unduly burden manufacturers and suppliers”.

The bill, introduced by Assembly member Tasha Boerner and sponsored by Californians Against Waste, sought to ban plastics and product companies from using systems often referred to as mass balance, free allocation or book and claim accounting.

These permit companies to purchase credits associated with recycled material from elsewhere in the global supply chain and claim high levels of recycled content even when it is scarcely in the product itself.

A shared goal of trust

In the letter, dated 27 September, Newsom said he shared Boerner’s goal of ensuring that environmental marketing claims are accurate and that consumers can trust the products they buy.

However, he claimed that manufacturers and suppliers already face “economic headwinds caused by federal tariff and trade policy actions”.

“Adding new, complex compliance requirements at this time risks compounding those pressures, with little benefit to consumers,” Newsom wrote. “For these reasons, I cannot sign this bill.”

In a statement, Boerner said the legislation would have protected consumers from deceptive recycled-content claims by requiring companies that advertise recycled content in their products to be honest about the amount of recycled material used.

‘Consumers deserve honest information’

“Businesses are lying about the recycled content in their products, frequently buying recycling credits and falsely claiming that their product has ‘100 per cent recycled content’,” said Boerner. “Consumers deserve honest information. Our planet and consumers cannot afford environmental deception.”

Kayla Robinson, legislative director at Californians Against Waste, added: “It’s disappointing that California is passing up an opportunity to bring basic truth and accountability to recycled-content claims.

“Consumers deserve to know whether the products they buy actually contain recycled material, not whether a company has purchased credits or relied on an accounting scheme. We will continue working to ensure that ‘made with recycled content’ means what Californians reasonably expect it to mean.”

Governor Gavin Newsom edited
Adding compliance requirements risks compounding current economic pressures with little benefit to consumers, says governor Newsom

California bill to ban mass balance vetoed by governor Newsom

Related content

Latest news

Sponsored content

California bill to ban mass balance vetoed by governor Newsom

Sign up to our newsletter to stay in the loop

Weekly news bulletin and monthly round-up